Article

Bankruptcies, Pensions and the Dodo Bird

Bankruptcies, Pensions and the Dodo Bird

Do you know what happens to former employees who were promised pensions or other benefits when a company goes bankrupt? Like trying to find an extinct Dodo Bird, you might have noticed that company pension plans seem to be disappearing. Tips to consider if you’re offered a lump-sum payment.

July 26, 2022
Bankruptcies, Pensions and the Dodo Bird
Important Disclosure: Content on our website and in our newsletters is for informational purposes only. The information provided may (or may not) directly apply to your situation. We recommend that readers work directly with a professional advisor when making decisions in the context of their specific situation.

When a company announces bankruptcy, employees usually lose their jobs and benefits. But what happens to former employees who were promised pensions or other benefits?

Well, a federal judge ruled that the Westmoreland Coal Company – one of the largest coal companies in the country – could end the health benefits for its former miners and families. And the decision has many retirees worried about their own health care and pensions. And rightly so.

Pensions and the Dodo Bird

Defined benefit pensions, long on the decline, continue to disappear. In fact, according to the Department of Labor, since 1983 US companies have eliminated over 125,000 defined benefit plans.

If you are in one of these traditional pensions, odds are that, sooner or later, you won’t be.

With traditional plans, called defined benefit, employees don’t contribute and companies put away the money for retirees to draw on. Under defined benefit plans, you get paid a specified amount, usually monthly, calculated based on your final salary and your years of service. The onus is on the employer to keep the plan funded, even though the amount needed is fluid and unpredictable, which is one big reason for companies to abandon them.

Why are Pensions Disappearing?

Why are company pensions evaporating? Partly because the Pension Protection Act of 2006 established new accounting rules under which companies with pension plans must recognize their plans’ funded status on their balance sheets each year.

Since analysts and investors scrutinize those balance sheets and lots of pension plans are underfunded, companies decided to take action - because underfunded plans constitute a corporate finance headache.

According to a Towers Watson survey, many companies with pension plans are trying to limit the effect of those plans on their financial statements and cash flows, as well as trying to reduce the overall cost of their plans. And to do that many are simply ditching their plans and giving employees lump sums.

Here’s what to know about your options.

If Offered a Lump-Sum

Why should you object to a wad of retirement cash all at once? Lump sums make sense if you expect to die soon without a surviving spouse who will need lifetime income. They also work if you already have another secure source of retirement income or are trained in handling such amounts of money at once.

In many other cases, accepting a lump sum payout rather than income from a pension may significantly affect your retirement funding unless you take proper steps.

Tips to consider:

  • Take your time. You can’t reverse your decision to take the lump sum.
  • Lump payouts may not include subsidized benefits that some employers offer as an incentive for early retirement.
  • Investing the sum in an immediate annuity might offer steady income into your retirement, but that income often falls short of inflation over time.

As you might after any large windfall, plan with a good financial advisor.

While pension plans are heading toward the same fate as the Dodo bird, your retirement benefits don’t have to.

Other content you may like

  • Mid-Quarter Roundtable Highlights

    Podcast Highlight - FTX Crypto Currency: Can that happen to my money?

    December 10, 2022
    The team shares insights about the blowup of the “get rich quick” crypto blockchain market and its relation to the established financial market. How is the stock or bond market any different? What can be learned from the volatility of a new asset class forming?
    Read this Article
  • Big Bounce in October and November

    Big Bounce in October and November

    December 19, 2022
    Many are questioning if the bounce in stocks is recent durable? For now, this past Oct. & Nov. performance for U.S. stocks is being counted in the top 15 “best 2-month” performances since 1950. This month’s Student of the Market also shows the 2022 YTD stats for market volatility and growth vs. value fund assets, as well a more insight into what’s going on with bonds.
    Read this Article
  • A married couple looking at each other sitting at a table.

    Maximizing Retirement Savings: The HSA

    October 2, 2025
    Have you heard about the tax benefits of using a Health Savings Account (HSA)? Discover how you can maximize savings and plan for future medical expenses. This quick read will share different tax advantages of having an HSA and how this may benefit you in the long-term.
    Read this Article
  • The Truth About Inflation and Risk

    The Truth About Inflation and Risk

    August 20, 2022
    Our Strong Valley advisor team recaps 2022 from May through August, where the US Bond market saw the worst start ever, and it was the 3rd-worse start for US Stocks. The team has a balanced discussion on winners and losers during times of inflation and what that means for investment risks. Questions from Strong Valley clients are answered, and the team showcases one practical way to objectively quantify and evaluate your own personal risk tolerance when it comes to investing. We wrap up the discussion with predictions and an outlook on where inflation and the markets may be headed in the months ahead.
    Read this Article
  • The link you have selected is located on another server. The linked site contains information that has been created, published, maintained, or otherwise posted by institutions or organizations independent of this organization. We do not endorse, approve, certify, or control any linked websites, their sponsors, or any of their policies, activities, products, or services. We do not assume responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of the information contained therein. Visitors to any linked websites should not use or rely on the information contained therein until they have consulted with an independent financial professional. Please click “Continue to Link” to leave this website and proceed to the selected site.
    phone-handset