Article

Carving Up Your Portfolio & Thanksgiving Pie

Carving Up Your Portfolio & Thanksgiving Pie

Diversification and Asset Allocation are important financial strategies that may bring many ideas and concepts to mind that aren’t necessarily how these tools are defined in a healthy portfolio. Here are some tips on how to examine your assets and have a more balanced portfolio pie.

November 23, 2021
Carving Up Your Portfolio & Thanksgiving Pie
Important Disclosure: Content on our website and in our newsletters is for informational purposes only. The information provided may (or may not) directly apply to your situation. We recommend that readers work directly with a professional advisor when making decisions in the context of their specific situation.

How do you carve up your portfolio pie to minimize risk and protect it from market troubles, like what we saw through Thanksgiving of 2018, for example?

Do you even remember that through Thanksgiving week 2018, the S&P 500 went negative, led by the FAANG group which officially entered bear market territory after dropping more than 20% from their 52-week highs? Probably not.

Do you even remember that shortly after Thanksgiving 2018, the S&P 500 kept posting red numbers on its way to a -9.18% return for the month of December 2018? Probably not.

Hopefully you will remember this: the best way to carve up your portfolio pie is through smart asset allocation, aided by diversification and rebalancing.

Diversification and Asset Allocation

Diversification means the mathematical process of reducing risk through the use of many different types of assets. Diversification combines mutual funds, ETFs, closed-end funds, stocks, bonds and other securities that are not correlated. In other words, one asset class typically zigs while the other zags. 

Asset allocation is when risk versus reward is balanced, according to the risk capacity, risk tolerance, time frame and goals of the investor. Many people believe that when they have more investments, it means they are more diversified.

Wrong.

Asset Allocation Pie

When allocating assets, you need to do two things:

  1. Find asset classes that are distinct and don’t overlap. You are not as diversified as you think if they do.
  2. Examine how they interact with each other. Different classes tend to do different things at different times.

So, it is not necessarily how many pieces you have in your pie, but what makes up the ingredients of the pieces to begin with. You have the entire global economy to locate them. You could cut the pie into very tiny pieces. However, those likely would be similar to other tiny pieces nearby.

A Better Pie

Work from the broader big picture on down, using specific investments for defined asset classes. And pay attention to rebalancing.

Rebalancing is a financial planning tool designed to get your portfolio back to your original allocation target. Why? Because with time your allocation drifts, and you take on a different risk profile as a result of this drift.

Rebalancing Your Pie

Let’s assume you are not investing in individual stocks, which may go to zero for a complete loss. Instead you invest in index funds, which give you steadier diversification.  By definition, all the companies in the index would need to go to zero for you to suffer a complete loss.

Let’s also assume you have a global asset allocation with indexed exposure to many different asset classes. What happens when, say, your Energy index fund declines and now makes up a smaller piece of your portfolio than you want in your asset allocation pie (the Energy sector is down over 40% YTD through November 20th)?

Or if the Information Technology portion of your portfolio is too big (the Information Technology sector is up over 30% through November 20th)?

Your next step is to rebalance.

You sell off a portion of your portfolio that has expanded too much and buy into the asset class that has declined. In other words, you sell some of the Information Technology index fund and buy more of the Energy index fund (this is just for illustrative purposes and not a recommendation to buy or sell one asset class for another by the way).

Remember the old saying, “Buy low, sell high?” Well, rebalancing means you are doing just that, except you sell high first, then buy low. You sell some of what has gone up to buy more of what has gone down, thus restoring your desired asset allocation pie and remaining consistent with your risk profile.

But beware: selling “winners” and buying “losers” goes against the grain emotionally, of course. So, you make this a regimen in order to eliminate some of the emotional challenges.

Pies and Financial Planning

You probably make pretty good pies. Your pies might even rival those from your grandmother. But asset allocation pies might taste better when constructed by a professional baker – your financial advisor.

  • Talk to your financial advisor about different types of pies (asset allocation).
  • Ask questions about the ingredients your financial advisor uses to make pies (diversification).
  • Recognize that sometimes you need to reduce the amount of nutmeg and add more cinnamon to make a pie that you like (rebalancing).

But most importantly, know that your financial advisor will create an asset allocation pie specifically tailored to your tastes (financial planning).

Happy Thanksgiving.

Other content you may like

  • The ABCs of Estate Planning

    September 3, 2025
    Do you need an estate plan? It’s not always a popular topic, but it’s an important consideration for everyone, regardless of income or age. Learn the basics of what’s covered in estate planning and how a professional can guide you through your unique circumstances.
    Read this Article
  • What to Do When the Bear Market Rallies

    What to Do When the Bear Market Rallies

    August 9, 2022
    The real value of a bear market may be that it gives investors, who are temporarily frozen within its grip, the opportunity to learn or relearn important lessons regarding risk and diversification. For savvy investors, a bear market also creates a period for looking beyond emotional headlines and studying the hard facts – facts that […]
    Read this Article
  • April Student of the Market

    April 29, 2025
    The first quarter of 2025 was very different from 2024, with international equities leading the way. How are the US “Mag 7” expected to perform going forward? Let’s take a look! In other news, is it a good time to buy? Finally, stock and bond correlations are changing.
    Read this Article
  • Roundtable Template

    Investments in Volatile Times

    May 26, 2022
    In this Mid-Quarter Roundtable Adam, Chris, Jason, and Kyle recap where we are at for 2022 so far, including inflation data, lower stocks, and lower bonds with rising interest rates. The team wraps up with where they see things going by the end of the year(-ish).  Along the way, they address common questions clients are asking right now.
    Read this Article
  • The link you have selected is located on another server. The linked site contains information that has been created, published, maintained, or otherwise posted by institutions or organizations independent of this organization. We do not endorse, approve, certify, or control any linked websites, their sponsors, or any of their policies, activities, products, or services. We do not assume responsibility for the accuracy, completeness, or timeliness of the information contained therein. Visitors to any linked websites should not use or rely on the information contained therein until they have consulted with an independent financial professional. Please click “Continue to Link” to leave this website and proceed to the selected site.
    phone-handset